Analysis of the Concept of the Legitimacy of Government; A Comparative Investigation of the Viewpoints of Thomas Aquinas and Khwajah Nasir al-Din al-Tusi

Ghorbanzadeh Savar, Ghorbanali; Izadi, Amir Mohammad

Analysis of the Concept of the Legitimacy of Government; A Comparative Investigation of the Viewpoints of Thomas Aquinas and Khwajah Nasir al-Din al-Tusi

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Ghorbanali Ghorbanzadeh Savar ¹

Amir Mohammad Izadi ²

¹ Assistance Professor of Political Philosophy Department, Imam Khomeini (R.A) International University

² MA in Political Science, Imam Khomeini (R.A) International University

Abstract

Legitimacy of government and trying to approve it is one of the important issues in politics. The present paper seeks to investigate the viewpoints of two great thinkers of the 13^th century, Thomas Aquinas and Khwajah Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, regarding the legitimacy of government; (Problem) an issue which has not been investigated so far. Since Aquinas was brought up in a Christian-European tradition and Khwajah Nasir al-Din al-Tusi in an Islamic-Iranian one, the present paper tries to answer this question: What are the basis and forms of the thoughts of these two thinkers regarding legitimacy of government? (Question) This term, because of conflicting conceptual interpretations in the viewpoint of different theorizers, has gained different meanings and forms, as a result, the present article is an exploratory one and there is no hypothesis presented for it. (No Hypothesis) Therefore, the purpose of this article is investigating the interpretations of these two great religious thinkers without any evaluation of their viewpoints. (Objective) Research data are collected using library documentary methods and are analyzed in the framework of comparative method. (Methodology) Despite the significant similarity in the theoretical principles of Aquinas and Khwajah, because of divine principles, these two viewpoints are in opposing poles, thus, it can be said that conceptualization of the legitimacy of government depends on the ground on which conceptualization takes place. (Finding)

Keywords

Thomas Aquinas

Khwajah Nasir al-Din

legitimacy

Government

Concept

and Politics

20.1001.1.23455705.1395.4.9.2.0

Amariles, David Restrepo (2008). Legality and Legitimacy: The Political Philosophy of Popular Sovereignty in the New Latin American Constitutions, Master in Legal Theory/Formation Doctorale en Théorie du Droit Katholieke Universiteit Brussel/Académie Universitaire de Louvain (FUSL) EUROPEAN ACADEMY OF LEGAL THEORY.

Ahmad, Irfan (2011). «Immanent critique and Islam: Anthropological reflections», Journal of Anthropological Theory, 11(1), p. 107-132.

Aquinas, St Thomas (1949). On Kingship to the King of Cyprus, United States, Pennsylvania State University.

________________ (2002). Aquinas: Political Writings, Edit and translate by R.W. DYSON, United Kingdo, Cambridge University Press.

________________ (2013). Summa Theologica, Unites states, Cosimo inc Volume 3 (Part II).

________________ (2014). The Summa Theologica: Complete Edition, translate by The Fathers of the English Dominican Province, London, Catholic Way Publishing.

Beetham, David (2013). The Legitimation of Power, Basingstoke, Palgrave.

Black, Antony (2011). The History of Islamic Political, United Kingdom, Edinburgh university press.

Coicaud, Jean-Marc (2002). Legitimacy and Politics: A Contribution to the Study of Political Right and Political Responsibility, UK, Cambridge University.

Groff, Peter S (2007). Islamic Philosophy A–Z, Scotland, Edinburgh University Press.

Habermas, Jürgen (1979). Communication and the Evolution of Society, translated by Thomas McCarthy, Boston, Beacon Press.

Jianping, LIU (2015). “The connotation of legitimacy and the historical evolution of Western political”, at International Conference on Social Science and Technology Education, part 1, Amsterdam, Atlantis Press, p. 460-462.

Kenny, Anthony (2006). A Brief History of Western Philosophy, United Kingdom. Blackwell publishing.

Nbete, Alubabari Desmond (2012).“The Social Contract Theory: A Model for Reconstructing a True Nigerian Nation-State International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, vol2, p. 267-278.

White, Michael (2012). Political Philosophy: An Historical Introduction, USA, Oxford University Press.